Final Fantasy Wiki
Line 25: Line 25:
 
== Thoughts on Deletion ==
 
== Thoughts on Deletion ==
   
Ten years later, Spoony is basically irrelevant as internet personalities are concerned. His site is down, he's been mostly forgotten, and frankly I'm not sure if this page is needed anymore. Any thoughts? {{User:BlueHighwind/Sig}} 21:40, October 8, 2019 (UTC)
+
Ten years later, Spoony is basically irrelevant as internet personalities are concerned. His site is down, he's been mostly forgotten, and frankly I'm not sure if this page is needed anymore. He's just a critic who had thoughts on these games years ago at this point, doesn't seem like much of a lasting legacy to remember. Any thoughts? {{User:BlueHighwind/Sig}} 21:40, October 8, 2019 (UTC)

Revision as of 21:42, 8 October 2019

ATTENTION
The Final Fantasy Wiki could not care less what your opinion of Noah Antwiler is. In addition, talk pages are not about the subject of the article, but rather the article itself. Any future;
  • expressing opinions about him here, or
  • requesting the page be deleted because of your opinions of him, and especially
  • threatening him or users of the wiki because of their opinions

will be deleted, and the latter will result in a ban.

Thanks,
The Management

page for deletion

its in the fandom category, his final fantasy reviews are hilarious and this wikia is filled with his quotes lol Judge Magister Pyarox 10:45, December 24, 2010 (UTC)

I don't see why the fact that he isn't a "Final Fantasy only" reviewer is enough reason for him to be "out of Scope" of this wiki. His two Final Fantasy reviews are quite famous amongst FF fans, and I'd say it's fair to have this article. At best, just don't go deep on his non FF work.

DiamondEdge 22:37, January 6, 2011 (UTC)

Result is: Kept. BLUER一番 17:03, January 16, 2011 (UTC)

Lordkat Incidents, TGWTG Incidents, and overall impact on internet video game reviewing type entertainment

https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=G9_isC31GFY

I'm not here to post e-gossip or tabloid garbage. I came upon this. https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=G9_isC31GFY

I plan to make something like this neutral and I have gone in depth on researching this matter of Noah due to wanting to provide neutral, unbiased, and informative entries regarding him due to not just his actions regarding his reviewing career, but also his career's impact due to his behavior and attitudes regarding allowing the reader to make a just and fair based conclusion on him. No, I am not including any major instances of his incidents (especially his sexual harassment incident and the drama on Lordkat.com). Just something to help balance this out.

Thoughts on Deletion

Ten years later, Spoony is basically irrelevant as internet personalities are concerned. His site is down, he's been mostly forgotten, and frankly I'm not sure if this page is needed anymore. He's just a critic who had thoughts on these games years ago at this point, doesn't seem like much of a lasting legacy to remember. Any thoughts? --BlueHighwind 21:40, October 8, 2019 (UTC)