Enough expository banter!
- Please sign and date your posts by typing four tildes (
~~~~) or five in a talk bubble. - Put new text under old text. Click here to start a new topic.
- Please read our Conduct guideline. In a nutshell: be polite, assume good faith.
- For general non-wiki discussion on this topic, feel free to discuss on Discord or Discussions.
This still needs further looking into to see if they're all the same. I know that FFVI/FFRK are the same, but what about all the other? Are they also Magus Robes too? | |||
So remember how I told you before about how the (second and third) kanji SE use for Mage isn't actually the normal kanji used for the word but is still pronounced the same?
Well T4HoL played on that. 道士のローブ is the "Monk Robe", 導師のローブ is the "Monkish Garb". They're both pronounced どうしのローブ [Dōshi no Rōbu]. :)
As for the others:
- 魔道士のローブ Madōshi no Rōbu - FF4TAY (Mage's Robe), FFTA (Magus Robe), FFTA2 (Magus Robe), FFD (Diviner's Robe)
- まどうしのローブ [hiragana form of above] - FF4:EasyType (Sage's Surplice: originally しさいのローブ)
- メイジローブ Meiji Rōbu - FFXI (Mage's Robe), FF12RW (Mage's Robes)
Don't know what FFXIV's section is about. There's Battlemage's Robe but that's not the same. JBed (talk) 11:14, February 22, 2017 (UTC)
Oh what, so 4HoL has two things pronounced the same exact way?? Whyyyyyyy?! And I suppose since they're both the same, BOTH of them have to go here. Also ugh...UGH! All the others aren't even the same as this one!? That's...really annoying. Which means I'll probably have to split Tao Robe off to its own little article for FFVI/4HoL/FFRK and leave this one for Madōshi no Rōbu, and...well, I guess Mage's Robe is going to be stuck as a disambig since I don't think those have any other appearances unless FFRK has a Mage's Robe, which I doubt it does. | |||
Well, the difference between the two robes in T4HoL is the same as the difference between Wizard's Staff and High Mage's Staff.
Although I did say we can't tell whether どうしのローブ is an appearance of 道士のローブ or an appearance of 導師のローブ, thanks to FFRK we actually can (it refers to 導師のローブ).
But since unlike High Mage's Staff, 道士のローブ only has a single appearance, it should stay on here for now (as it's a parody/reference to 導師のローブ). I'll add a note about the names after the page gets dealt with. JBed (talk) 22:57, February 22, 2017 (UTC)
Hmm...so the problem now is...well...how do we separate the articles? This is still Magus Robe for the FFVI/4HoL/FFRK armor, but the TAY/FFTA/FFTA2/FFD is also Magus Robe according to the most recurring name. It can't be Mage's Robe for that one either, because of the FFXI/RW armor. And I don't think we can use Diviner's Robe for that first one either...hmmm... | |||
Just putting this here, it's the same as what you already put, but it's to help me think on what to do with this. Or try to anyways...still haven't thought of how to handle this dumb article.
| |||