FANDOM


Gilgamesh-ffv-ios-portrait
Gilgamesh: Enough expository banter!
This talk page is used for discussing improvements to the page "Garlemald". It is not the place for general discussion or sharing stories about the topic of this article.
Take a good look. Isn't it beautiful?
FF5Crystal Behold! This article has been chosen as the Featured Article of November 15th, 2011!
Even so, if you wish to improve the article, do not hesitate! You can also nominate your favorite articles to be featured here!

Garlean character page namesEdit

Followup to my most recent edit regarding the malleability of Garlean middle names, a change to their character pages might be in order. The Garlean middle name isn't so much a name as a title, a title that can change or be removed as the story progresses - calling a character Aulus mal Asina is basically the same as calling him Doctor Aulus Asina. Gaius van Baelsar is the same as General Gaius Baelsar. Varis zos Galvus is the same as Emperor Varis Galvus. Were Raubahn Aldynn a Garlean legatus rather than Flame General, he'd be Raubahn van Aldynn - his first and last name stick, now he's just got the added title.

As noted in my edit, we've already got examples of the title changing or being removed. Varis was "promoted" from Yae to Zos when his ascended. Fordola was explicitly referred to simply as Fordola Lupis in 4.1 rather than Fordola rem Lupis. There's the example of Eula Darnus - we simply don't know her rank in Garlean society and as such have no middle name to refer to her by. And the newly introduced Jenomis cen Lexentale says that Jenomis is simply his stage name and that his real name Arazlam Durai - no middle name added, despite the fact the he is still a pureblood Garlean and that is should be Arazlam cen Durai.

I'm not really going to push for this, like, at all, as the Garlean middle names are largely very tied to their character, but a case can certainly be made to remove the middle name from the page name. Resulting pages would be:

--Adonzo (talk) 23:16, October 13, 2017 (UTC)

Naming scheme explanation would be good in this page, and in characters' etymology sections.Keltainentoukokuu (talk) 18:10, October 14, 2017 (UTC)
You might be right, but the game script referred to them as such, and they're known to the players by these full names. Monterossa (talk) 21:11, October 14, 2017 (UTC)
I've been looking and it seems that Varis may not be the only one who is known to have their "middle name" changed. Before becoming Legatus of the XIVth, Gaius van Baelsar was Tribunus Angusticlavius of the XIth, so he was known as Gaius sas Baelsar on those times. --Con Carne (Di la verdad, o cobras...) 18:45, December 9, 2018 (UTC)
Just to bring this up again, once again in regards to Gaius, once Shadowhunter reveals himself to be Gaius, he clarifies that he is simply Gaius Baelsar, not Gaius van Baelsar, making a point of dropping the particle. Someone has already changed the opening paragraph on his page to read as Gaius Baelsar with no mention of the van, so some kind of ruling should really be made on this. --Adonzo (talk) 11:09, March 6, 2019 (UTC)
I don't think we should do it that way. The introduction on each character page should focus about their status at the beginning of the game. Monterossa (talk) 12:54, March 6, 2019 (UTC)

About the Garlean raceEdit

Not all of the Garlean citizens are of the Garlean race, correct? Cid for the example, he was a Garlean citizen but he looks like a Hyur. Grynewaht is obviously a Roegadyn. Monterossa (talk) 08:19, February 9, 2018 (UTC)

That is correct1 In fact, Stormblood clarified a lot of this on its plot. I mean, people that weren't born in Garlemand can still be Garlean, like Yotsuyu and her brother or Fordola rem Lupis. It's like nationalities in our own world, you may not be born in one place, but that doesn't mean you can obtain the nationality of that place. -- Eco (talk) 08:24, February 9, 2018 (UTC)
Then we need to correct some of the Garlean character pages with "Race: Garlean" in their infobox. Is there an official name for the Garlean race though? Monterossa (talk) 08:26, February 9, 2018 (UTC)
I don't think "Garlean" is actually a race. Maybe yes, a race such as "Eorzean", "Othardian", "Thavnarian"... But not in a same way as "Hyur", "Lalafell", "Au Ra"... Nael for example may be considered actually as a Garlean Midlander Hyur in the same way Raubahn is an Ala Mhigan Highlander Hyur. However it may have some differences as well (besides the "third eye"), for example: it seems that Garlean Midlander Hyurs are taller than other Midlanders. Just like Othardian Roegadyn are different from the western ones. I don't know if I'm clear. ^¬^; --Con Carne (Di la verdad, o cobras...) 18:45, December 9, 2018 (UTC)
From what Aulus mal Asina said, it seems to be a race. They're giraffe-like humans that are stronger and smarter than other races, but cannot use magics. They're different enough to be considered a race IMO. Aulus also said that the Garleans were oppressed by "other races" and were driven to Ilsabard. Monterossa (talk) 19:35, December 9, 2018 (UTC)

FWIW, Cid absolutely is of the garlean race. His third eye is seen near the end of ARR, he just covers it with his goggles. --Adonzo (talk) 04:08, December 10, 2018 (UTC)

MembersEdit

In the spanish wiki I've made a different version of the "notable members" section, and I ask if you're interested to make it here as well. The section would be cataloged into Legions (except for those whose Legion is/was unknown).

Just suggesting, I won't do anything. --Con Carne (Di la verdad, o cobras...) 18:45, December 9, 2018 (UTC)

Community content is available under CC-BY-SA unless otherwise noted.