FANDOM


Line 18: Line 18:
 
{{MC|06:49, 9 June 2009 (UTC)|I am happy to see a decision. Before ILHI and I shout, "Take it to the MoS!" I would request that #4's "more often than not" be a phrase at least closer to "always." My opinion is that we need the rules to be as close to Boolean (all or nought) as possible.}}
 
{{MC|06:49, 9 June 2009 (UTC)|I am happy to see a decision. Before ILHI and I shout, "Take it to the MoS!" I would request that #4's "more often than not" be a phrase at least closer to "always." My opinion is that we need the rules to be as close to Boolean (all or nought) as possible.}}
 
{{ILHI|14:44, 9 June 2009 (UTC)|Misters and Missuses should be the only exception IMO. And even then, I'm only saying that because [[Mr. Monkey]] MUST keep his pagename (Unless the wiki decides to use my favourite ext.abbv. policy) because his surname isn't actually Monkey. Actually, in the case of everyone else without a first name, just their surname is fine.<br><br>I still vote for the removal of Judge and Judgemasters. The Judges are called by their surname in boss battles I believe, which means it's fine for the developers to call them that. In the case of Gabranth....... Wait a second? Why is he called Gabranth? Surely he should be Judge Rosenburg or whatever? I know, that would be SPOILERISH as they try to hide the relation, but seriously? Is the Judge naming policy their surname? Anyway, in the case of Gabranth, he should be called "Gabranth", just like Golbez isn't called "Theodor Harvey".<br><br>Anyway, requesting "Edea Kramer" move to "Edea" and requesting "Raine Loire" move to "Raine". These names are the most spoilerish on the wiki. And I'm sure there are probably a few other cases where there are spoilerish redirects where two different people are actually the same person. I vaguely remember something somewhere in the Tactics series.}}
 
{{ILHI|14:44, 9 June 2009 (UTC)|Misters and Missuses should be the only exception IMO. And even then, I'm only saying that because [[Mr. Monkey]] MUST keep his pagename (Unless the wiki decides to use my favourite ext.abbv. policy) because his surname isn't actually Monkey. Actually, in the case of everyone else without a first name, just their surname is fine.<br><br>I still vote for the removal of Judge and Judgemasters. The Judges are called by their surname in boss battles I believe, which means it's fine for the developers to call them that. In the case of Gabranth....... Wait a second? Why is he called Gabranth? Surely he should be Judge Rosenburg or whatever? I know, that would be SPOILERISH as they try to hide the relation, but seriously? Is the Judge naming policy their surname? Anyway, in the case of Gabranth, he should be called "Gabranth", just like Golbez isn't called "Theodor Harvey".<br><br>Anyway, requesting "Edea Kramer" move to "Edea" and requesting "Raine Loire" move to "Raine". These names are the most spoilerish on the wiki. And I'm sure there are probably a few other cases where there are spoilerish redirects where two different people are actually the same person. I vaguely remember something somewhere in the Tactics series.}}
{{PM|...This may be a bit crazy, but how about...
+
{{PM|text=...This may be a bit crazy, but how about...
   
 
Leave Judge Gabranth as he normally is and make a new article about "Noah fon Ronsenburg" from before he was known as Judge Gabranth. This is like Wikipedia having seperate articles for Anakin Skywalker and Darth Vader.}}
 
Leave Judge Gabranth as he normally is and make a new article about "Noah fon Ronsenburg" from before he was known as Judge Gabranth. This is like Wikipedia having seperate articles for Anakin Skywalker and Darth Vader.}}

Revision as of 15:40, June 9, 2009

FFWiki forum logo
Forums: Index > Rin's Travel Agency > Archive > Titled characters


Galbana-ffxiirw
Rikku White Mage

Template:ILHI

Chibi-Unita


Community content is available under CC-BY-SA unless otherwise noted.