Enough expository banter!
- Please sign and date your posts by typing four tildes (
~~~~
) or five in a talk bubble. - Put new text under old text. Click here to start a new topic.
- Please read our Conduct guideline. In a nutshell: be polite, assume good faith.
- For general non-wiki discussion on this topic, feel free to discuss on Discord or Discussions.
Archives | ||
---|---|---|
|
This talk page has the purpose of helping to select what will eventually be our semi-weekly competition. If you would like to make a suggestion, please feel free to leave it here. If you would like to see what people have suggested in the past, please refer to this page's archive.
Queued
The following were archived and will probably eventually be put up as actual fights some week. They appear in no particular order.
- Locke v. Zidane
- Turn v. ATB v. Realtime
- Zack v. Cloud
- Garland v. Kuja
- Basch/Gabranth v. Edgar/Sabin
- Garnet v. Ashe
- Balthier v. Auron
- Tidus v. Squall
- Vayne v. Seymour
- Cid Highwind v. Cid of FFXII
- Kain Highwind v. Ricard
HERE'S AN IDEA! LETS HAVE GOOD FIGHTS!
Maverick King - You are not a Snake and I am not an Ocelot. We are men with names. TALK - When the lambs stopped screaming {{{time}}} | |||
I'm sick of all this bullshit fights. The "who's the best ninja" "who's the most annoying bitch" Lets just have fights for the sake of fights damnit! Stuff like Auron against Basch. Beatrix against Terra. There doesn't have the be any relation or connection, they just decide to meet in a steel cage (or mud pit for the ladies) and wail on each other. Whose with me on this? | |||
Me! (TA is so giving us tests for "not following etiquette) | |||
I got an idea, Balthier vs. Shadow and settle the Ninjas vs. Pirates crap once and for all | |||
Maverick King - You are not a Snake and I am not an Ocelot. We are men with names. TALK - When the lambs stopped screaming {{{time}}} | |||
YEAH! The Kuja v. Garland fight sounds exactly what I had in mind. No similarities just ass whooping! | |||
Beatrix vs. Celes
Battle of the Women Generals.
Support
- ChiefKakashi 00:36, 7 March 2008 (UTC)
- This fight would be badass.Moogle king 14:39, 7 March 2008 (UTC)
- Crazyswordsman: Sure. Why not?
- Adam mcduck: I think it would be good.
- Khakishro: I think this is a great Idea, though I think Beatrix would win...
- Blackheart1991: I'm game for that.
- TheSwordofDoubt: I like the sound of it.
Reject
Comments
8bit_BlackMage: I don't reject this, I would love to see this fight, but Beatrix has already had a battle about a month ago. It will probably be another two months before this fight will even be considered.
Garland vs. Emperor Palamecia
Battle of the first two villains in Final Fantasy? The original two that are set as an example for later villains in Final Fantasy series. Oath to Order 05:02, 7 March 2008 (UTC)
Support
Reject
Comments
Garland would win easily because nobody remembers/knows about/cares about Emperor Palamecia. No offense meant....just an observation. --Fyrmer
User:Henryacores:I would support this if it was Ultimecia vs Mateus Palamecia.
Terra vs. Zidane
A clash of the Trance-ers! Both are awesome characters with mysterious pasts, both goes into Trances that greatly increase their fighting power, and both have a dark connection to the antagonist of their respective games. Drake Clawfang 05:58, 7 March 2008 (UTC)
Support
- Very original--N/A
- Oath to Order 06:38, 7 March 2008 (UTC)
- User:Henryacores: If Zidane may be a rip-off of dragonball, but he's much cooler than Goku or anyone else from DBZ.
- User:Kami strife: I like it. A fight like this would be pretty amusing.
Reject
- i like this idea but it might be one sided.alot of people love terra while zidane....people hate him because people thinks hes a ripoff from dragonball like another user said.Moogle king 14:42, 7 March 2008 (UTC)
- Pablo618: I don't think there is a criteria over here :S every character in FFIX can trance so Vivi would fit a bit more than Zidane
- Crazyswordsman: Terra doesn't trance. She Morphs. Get it right.
Comments
Hell no. Zidane will always be much more badass than that friggin emo bitch.--N/A
Moogle_king - Sticking feathers up your butt does not make you a chocobo TALK - i have no need time,do you? {{{time}}} | |||
this is already becoming one sided.... | |||
Battle of the Skill Acquisition Tables
How about a battle between FFX's Sphere Grid and FFXII's Licence Board?
Support
Reject
- Both are crappy. --Alcaeus
- License Board kicks Sphere Grid's rectum. I hated all those locks on the Grid. --Airemir 17:59, 22 March 2008 (UTC)
- Certain people here (like me) lack brain cells, and as such forget to vote for the best one - a.k.a. Sphere Grid. --Auron Kaizer 21:51, 22 March 2008 (UTC)
- User:Henryacores: Yuck...Imagine the images that they would choose for this. Besides, Sphere Grid would kick Licence Grid's ass. Licence Grid doesn't give you half the bonuses that Sphere grid does.
- I flipped a coin and got tails.
Comments
Seifer Almasy vs Sephiroth
Gunblade vs Masamune
Support
Reject
- This is a horrible idea, although it would be amusing to see what would likely be the first shut-out victory in DNC history. Drake Clawfang
- Crazyswordsman: NO NO NO
- Siefer has no where near the fans or abilities to defeat sephiroth.
- NO WAY, Sephiroth has a better personality and is much cooler then Siefer.
Comments
seifer, obviously. sephiroth is cool and what not, but seifer has a better attitude
- User:Kami strife: Well, I like Seifer more, but Sephiroth would drop kick Seifer to Mars and back if they ever fought. He's just physcotically strong. Sorry, Seifer.
Gun-wielders: Barrett Vs Balthier
One's badass and the other is suave, both are packing (who wants to not give Balthier guns, really?). I think this is good because both are popular and it ain't one sided: ffvii fanboys can be easily outnumbered here.
Support
Reject
Comments
You haven't been here very long, huh? | |||
Yeah. All Balthier battles automatically get rigged, so no point in doing it. I'd have thought you'd know better than to spam votes with different IPs now CSM... | |||
Anyone who's seen the Balthier vs. Cloud fight know that anything with Balthier would be totally one-sided. | |||
battle of the weapons: sword vs. staff vs. gunblade!
hey what is the best weapon, eh? definitly gunblade!
Support
Gunblade's would so win because they have the longer blades so they they could hit you way before a sword could even touch you
Reject
- Boring and Gunblades are ridiculous weapons. Swords would win because staves are generally magic weapons. --Alcaeus
- Technically gunblades are gun-shaped swords.
Comments
CSM Vs BH
support
- Cloudofdarkness 14:42, 12 March 2008 (UTC)
- No way in hell this is happending,because this will start a damn holy war.But i want to have front row seats of this theather of mass destruction anyway.Moogle king 21:05, 12 March 2008 (UTC)
- ChiefKakashi 21:08, 12 March 2008 (UTC)
- I have to support this one since it isn't about FF. --Alcaeus
- Naruto is li3k s0 c00l l0l l00k at my us1rn4m3!!!!: It's like America vs. China. As long as both perish or become leper colonies, it's fine. I'm not even sure who I'd vote for...probably ChiefKakashi!
- Pablo618: VOTE!!!!!
reject
- Yay Im different. But seriously who cares. It's not like anyone will remember this in a centrillion years. Besides me of course, but Im immortal.
comments
The most known admin against the most known... Blue guy? Well, any comments | |||
Crazyswordsman - Final Fantasy VI, because Drake says he wants to link to FF7 every day, which is bad because that game is so far inferior to FF6. TALK - 22:47, 12 March 2008 (UTC) | |||
This isn't even a contest since I have the ban button sitting right above me and BH doesn't. | |||
You can't ban us without a reason...right? | |||
Some day... | |||
I figure if I stay around long enough, I'll get rollback rights from BH. Although sooner would be nice... | |||
Crazyswordsman - Final Fantasy VI, because Drake says he wants to link to FF7 every day, which is bad because that game is so far inferior to FF6. TALK - 22:59, 12 March 2008 (UTC) | |||
No...I was joking. | |||
You want Rollback Rights? Here you go. You now have the ability to roll backwards. Enjoy it. | |||
.................... | |||
I knew you were joking, just wanted to make sure *laughs akwardly | |||
@AK: Down to baseless "insults" are we? | |||
Insult? Why no sir! I was just emphatically making reference to the abundance of Naruto-related nicknames in this day and age. But if you do feel insulted, I've got a moist towelette you can use. | |||
You get a cookie for guessing where the first half of his name comes from. | |||
Seifer vs basch
Support
- I'd like to give this one a chance. -- ChiefKakashi 02:04, 13 March 2008 (UTC)
- SCM: Cause I wanna see Seifer get his ass kicked
Reject
- Crazyswordsman: Too one sided. Anything with an FFVIII character would be one sided. Although I would like to see Basch kill Seifer.
- Basically what CSM said, too one sidedCloudofdarkness 03:44, 13 March 2008 (UTC)
- You're completely loco. Basch will chop Seifer to bits. Gunblade or no. --Airemir 17:06, 22 March 2008 (UTC)
Comments
I couldn't find anybody person outside of ff8 that wouldn't be better.Seifer Gunblade 02:02, 13 March 2008 (UTC) well,maybe Vincent and Kimahri. Alot of fight wouldn't be one sided with FF8.
Triple Triad VS Tetra Master
Not sure if this one has been done but if not..then it's time! The best card games ever made fighting each other! Throw an Ark card and see if you turn the Squall card! So who wins, FFVIII's Triple Triad, or FFIX 's Tetra Master?
Support
201.6.145.188 13:54, 13 March 2008 (UTC)
Reject
Cloudofdarkness 14:11, 13 March 2008 (UTC)
Comments
Knights of the Round VS Eden VS Ark VS Zodiac
The top summons of the FF PS era. Them all destroy. Them all rocks. Them all takes one, two minutes just to deal damage! So, who wins?
Support
- 201.6.145.188 13:54, 13 March 2008 (UTC)
- I believe this idea was hawked off of my Sandbox, but I will support it. 8bit BlackMage 02:16, 16 March 2008 (UTC)
- AK's 115th Dream: If you remove Zodiac (or his original translated name in FFT, Zodapop) since he really isn't part of Final Fantasy, sure.
Reject
Comments
Too many damn veruses!!!!
Battle of the Statue-Gods
How about a battle between the deities of VI and XII? Both (permanently or temperarily) took the form of statues, both caused their worlds more harm than good, and both's inner strugles were used by the main antagonist (Kefka took advantage of their petrification, Vayne took advantage of Venat's desperation). So, how about it?
For the record, Promathia is a statue until you fight him too! | |||
For the record, nobody gives a flying handbag! | |||
Zack versus Laguna
Neither one was the predominant antagonist of their respective game, but they both heavily influenced them. I think this would be interesting and not incredibly one-sided. --Blykus
Support
- I'll support this, since I came up with it. --Blykus
- I like laguna because i like FF8,BITCHES!
Reject
- NO NO NO NO NO LAGUNA IS A FUCKING MORON AND NO ONE LIKES HIM!!!!!! --Alcaeus
- One sided, for the above stated reasons.--Otherarrow
- See above. Although I'd vote for Laguna in this one. --Crazyswordsman 03:19, 14 March 2008 (UTC)
- Too many FFVII Fanboys for this to be fair.
Comments
Wow, didn't think people disliked Laguna. I'm a fan of his, though I'm not sure which one of these two I'd end up voting for. They're both pretty awesome, in my opinion. | |||
You'll find that with a few exceptions, VIII and all related concepts are hated throughout this wiki.
| |||
And yet, FFVIII related pages are among the completed ones in the Wiki. Character pages? Abilities? Enemy pages? Terms? Locations? All prepared. Haters are all talk and no action. | |||
A battle of Black Mages
|
AlcaeusTheWizard - is now actually contributing...well, not really TALK - Force shites upon Reason's back. -Ben Franklin, Poor Richard's Almanack, 1736. {{{time}}} | |||
Kytes isn't a black mage, he's an NPC. Vivi is God. | |||
He may be but Vivi can go in Trance and what can Kytes do um um um ,oh yeah NOTHING! | |||
bob the geomancer - Do you know what cancer is? it is a piece of evil. TALK - I had a dog once. cancer overtook him {{{time}}} | |||
Actually he can do a heavy damage attack (Kytes is one of the best Characters combat wise, Lluyd being the best story wise) | |||
AlcaeusTheWizard - is now actually contributing...well, not really TALK - Force shites upon Reason's back. -Ben Franklin, Poor Richard's Almanack, 1736. {{{time}}} | |||
Vivi vs. Aeris?
Crazyswordsman - Final Fantasy VI, because Drake says he wants to link to FF7 every day, which is bad because that game is so far inferior to FF6. TALK - 17:37, 16 March 2008 (UTC) | |||
This is a fight I kinda wanna see at some point... | |||
Support
- Duh. --Crazyswordsman 17:36, 16 March 2008 (UTC)
- Zolo6 agrees!
- Nagato15 thinks this is a kickass idea!
- BlueHighwind I always am in support of any fight that will piss off a few fanboys.
- Alcaeus Hell, it's not like we're going to have a good DNC fight for a long time, so why not? Plus, I want to see Vivi kill Aeris.
Reject
- See the above fight'sreasons for rejection. Aeris may garner more support than Kytes, but there is no way she could beat Vivi. 8bit BlackMage 18:23, 16 March 2008 (UTC)
- CSM obviously just wants to see Aeris get pwned. Vivi won MM, so this is overly one-sided. -- ChiefKakashi 18:27, 16 March 2008 (UTC)
- Vivi won Magicite madness, Aeris is hated here because she died. Obvious shut out. Cloudofdarkness 14:59, 17 March 2008 (UTC)
Comments
Sounds more better than my idea,the greatest black mage(i guess) vs. the greatest white mage | |||
Aeris, the greatest White Mage? Oh no my boy. That title belongs to Minwu from FFII. | |||
LMAO, I'm not even gonna comment on what you just said there Blue. But yeah, she's not. | |||
What you mean she is greatest and Minwu and her are the same so don't judge,because they both died in the story dealing with magic,duh! | |||
- I'm choking over reject vote 4. Oh gods, that hurts. Question: why do people always question sexual preference when insulting someone? So strange... -- YuanchosaanSalutations! 11:43, 8 April 2008 (UTC)
AlcaeusTheWizard - is now actually contributing...well, not really TALK - Force shites upon Reason's back. -Ben Franklin, Poor Richard's Almanack, 1736. {{{time}}} | |||
I removed it, because I CAN. | |||
- Thank you Alcaeus, that was a blight on this wiki ^-^. Also, I think the rules are being revised, Blue has suggested that we limit the use of talk templates -- YuanchosaanSalutations! 11:49, 9 April 2008 (UTC)
FFXII villans fight
Vayne Solidor vs Cidolfus (Cid)
Support
Reject
- Nagato15
- Crazyswordsman: I...really don't see where this is coming from.
- Uh...NO. Just no.--Airemir 16:58, 22 March 2008 (UTC)
Comments
Battle of the Ditzes
support
reject
commentsI have a feeling this will be next week's fight....it could be just me though. 8bit BlackMage 16:55, 22 March 2008 (UTC) How come this fight wasn't picked? I'm not only saying this because it's my fight but it also only had 1 Reject vote and more Support votes than Edge and Shadow and any other fight suggested on here. If it was because of the coding I had it all on my sandbox page. Just click the italicised words on my opening statment. -Azul 05:11, 27 March 2008 (UTC)
Thanks CSM. I have since cooled down. Sorry for the whining. -Azul 07:41, 28 March 2008 (UTC) |
Imperial Cities Fight
A bit of an improvement of my last suggestion. How about we do a fight between two Imperial cities, Archades and Vector? Cactuar83File:Highwind.jpgHighwind 02:01, 21 March 2008 (UTC)
Support
- Another FFVI rout. Sure, Archades has got +1,000,000 NPCs with their useless backstories and that completely enraging "sandalwood" quest, but Vector has...THE JUGGERNAUT BITCH! And that guy who tells the world's coolest backstory about Kefka. --Auron Kaizer 00:45, 22 March 2008 (UTC)
- User:Kami strife:I think this would be pretty amusing. Although it's not a typical bout between characters, something like this would be a nice change of pace.
Reject
- Zolo:Ok wierd idea?
- Quoting High Summoner Yuna, "Let's not."--Airemir 17:00, 22 March 2008 (UTC)
- I want characters to fight, not cities. -- ChiefKakashi 22:14, 22 March 2008 (UTC)
Comments
heros battle
Basch and Auron two of my favorites characters Basch (FFXII) vs Auron (FFX)
Pretenious Fruit
Redneck
- I wanna be a redneck Basch suppoter! -- ChiefKakashi 22:32, 22 March 2008 (UTC)
Comments
Who the hell is Basch, and no. | |||
Now its fair. | |||
Really who the heck is Basch do you mean Basch?Really I like these to but really NO everyone knows Auron will win | |||
How about we do a Vaan Morrison vs. Balflear vs. Vasch vs. Viena Carrotass Solidox? | |||
Battle of Freaks in Armor
Support
Both are half-decent characters, get to it. --Auron Kaizer 18:25, 24 March 2008 (UTC)
Reject
Comments
FFI Garland is better... | |||
tidus vs shuyin
woulded it be cool the dream vs the real one
Axel vs. Reno
The Turk vs. the Flurry of Dancing Flames. Seriously, the resemblance is too close to ignore. The same color of hair, both have a weird mark on their faces, and they even have the same voice actors in English and Japanese. I mean, come on.--Mjka 04:14, 30 March 2008 (UTC)
Support
That would be cool. I was actually gonna suggest that fight but you bet me to it. It could be a little one sided for final fantasy players who have not played the kingdom hearts series may not know who Axel is and think he is a jerk, but it would be an amusing and fun battle (both have anger problems) ZatchD
- Khakishro: I'm ok with with this, but would everyone else be...
Reject
Comments
Not a Fight. Just a comment
The page takes along time for it to load. Should we start deleting the fights that have been mainly rejected or have no votes? | |||
We can archive them and the ones that have already been done? Keep the ones that are getting positive responses? | |||
Seifer Almasy vs Cloud
Support
Reject
- Hasn't every fansite from here to Timbuktu already done this one? --BlueHighwind
- User:Kami strife: I think that this would be pretty one-sided. Cloud all the way.
Vivi vs Balthier
The winner of Magicite Madness vs a guy who is worshipped by almost everyone here. -- Alcaeus
Support
- Balthier got beat out by Tifa in MM, so we never got to see this fight. -- ChiefKakashi 20:46, 2 April 2008 (UTC)
- Yes, I like Vivi but this will be interesting to see what others think.
Reject
Comments
Sexy Black Mages
edea vs lulu for best female black mage -- Fonzyboi
Support
- Any fight with my girl Edea in it is A-okay in my book. --BlueHighwind
- This sounds good. -- ChiefKakashi
- newbie here. like to hear from u guys who's hotter -- Fonzyboi
- Interesting idea. Although Vivi is sexier. :D --Crazyswordsman 07:50, 4 April 2008 (UTC)
- This sounds like it could definitely go well. --Blykus 02:33, 5 April 2008 (UTC)
- VIII character's rarely get battles & Edea is one of the best, so why not. Adam mcduck
- Khakishro: Its orginal, and what Mcduck said is so true.
- This should be the next fight. 8bit BlackMage 23:47, 6 April 2008 (UTC)
- Hell yes. Dark raven 19:40, 12 April 2008 (UTC)
Reject
Comments
Yevon vs Venat
BATTLE OF THE GODS!
Support
- Interesting idea. --Crazyswordsman 05:46, 6 April 2008 (UTC)
- I like it, a lot.
- If Chiefkakashi can vote on his/her own idea then so can I. Sorry for not knowing your gender, but Im new around here.
Reject
- Yevon is a false religion. The Church of Glabados is also a false religion. Shouldn't they be the ones fighting? --BlueHighwind 23:12, 6 April 2008 (UTC)
- Meh. -- ChiefKakashi 23:51, 6 April 2008 (UTC)
Comments
- Random, but how do you make a new section to suggest a fight?
- BlueHighwind is wrong. Yevon was the first summoner and the religion was inspired by him. Although his name is technically Yu Yevon. Sorry for not specifying that. Im immortal.
Tifa vs.Sephiroth
Not fanservice! These are the most popular VII characters (in the wiki...I think), so I want to see who will win. -- ChiefKakashi 23:21, 6 April 2008 (UTC)
Support
Comments
Cid Highwind vs. Doctor Cid
BEHOLD THE BATTLE OF THE CIDS! Two Cids, but only one can be the best. So, who's it gonna be. It's all up to you.
Support
- ChiefKakashi 23:40, 6 April 2008 (UTC)
Reject
- This was already decided in the Sweet Sixteen. --Crazyswordsman 02:42, 7 April 2008 (UTC)
Comments
Sora vs. Roxas
They may be the same exact person, but who do you like better. The optimistic, somewhat temperamental, gullible Sora, or the serious, more mysterious Roxas. Your choice.
Support
Reject
- This isn't the Kingdom Hearts Wiki. Plus Sora is the obvious winner. --BlueHighwind 23:48, 6 April 2008 (UTC)
- Go start a Hercules colosseum or something. --Crazyswordsman 02:44, 7 April 2008 (UTC)
- I think that you guys are being a bit harsh. But you do have a point: this is a Final Fantasy wiki. --Kami strife 21:12, 9 April 2008 (UTC)
Comments
- Not my fault Kingdom Hearts Wiki doesn't have this. And I've only played FF12.
Member of SOLDIER vs. Sky Pirates
Both great fighters, SOLDIER with fighters like Cloud, Sephiroth, and Zack and the Sky Pirates with memorable pairs like Balthier and Fran, Vaan and Penelo, or solo pirates like Reddas.
Support
Reject
- ChiefKakashi 23:50, 6 April 2008 (UTC)
- Far too broad. Try narrowing it down to less than 50 people.
Comments
Tifa vs Balthier
Guy who is worshipped by everyone vs girl who is worshipped by everyone (or there abouts.) YuanchosaanSalutations! 23:49, 7 April 2008 (UTC)
Support
- ChiefKakashi 23:58, 7 April 2008 (UTC)
- Blykus 03:07, 8 April 2008 (UTC)
- Kami strife 18:41, 8 April 2008 (UTC)
- JARIITX 23:27, 13 April 2008 (UTC)
Comments
Auron vs. Basch
This has either been done, or I'm a genious...Probably the former. -- ChiefKakashi 21:38, 9 April 2008 (UTC)
Support
Comments
Freya vs. Fran
They are both 'humanoids', one is a rat the other is a rabbit. It's rodent fight. -- VulpineNinja 11 April 2008
Support
- ChiefKakashi 05:53, 11 April 2008 (UTC)
- Blykus 08:51, 11 April 2008 (UTC)
- Dark raven 19:39, 12 April 2008 (UTC)
Comments
New Rules Suggestion
Okay, following on from Blue's suggestions, here's some suggestions for an "official" rule set:
- 1 support column, 1 comment column; no rejects
- No talk templates
- Sign your suggestions/votes/comments
- Don't vote for your own suggestion
- Ignore the fights that you're not interested in
- 5+ votes and it gets queued? (perhaps we should have a seperate page for queued fights?)
- If a suggestion is there for 2 weeks without five votes, archive it. (Archive no votes at 1 week?)
- No duplicate fights (unless it hasn't happened in more than a year)
- New fights at the bottom (helps archiving)
Obviously, it needs to be ordered properly. Thoughts? YuanchosaanSalutations! 07:23, 9 April 2008 (UTC)
- You might also put in: "TA has the final say in the selection of fights". All else, I support. [^_^]/ 14:02, 9 April 2008 (UTC)
Reject
<3 --TacticAngel 18:18, 9 April 2008 (UTC)
Apologies upon changing the format on suggesting fights
Apparently yet ironically the fight suggestions format has become the DNC itself, for that, I must apologize, I originally planned this way so that things are more sorted and easier too read, with TA holding the final judge upon wanting to use the ideas or not, even so, it seems that the "support" and "reject" greatly affects the results, and therefore things would get pretty boring and predictable. Once again, sorry. | |||
What do you mean? It works about the same as the old way of doing it, it's just a lot more organized. | |||
IMHO, the reject and comment columns were unnecessary. If a person wants to support, just sign it and leave some remarks after the signature; if one is to reject, then ignore or support another suggestion. Also, a good practice is to limit the use of TalkText here as much as in the DNC itself. Loading can sometimes be pretty slow for some people to view the suggestions made. Additionally, some limits should be made on a suggestion, perhaps a quota to be reached before the suggestion is erased or archived due to no support. The suggestion page will be much more organized. Organization makes it easy for everyone. | |||
Agree on changing the format from Support/Reject/Comments to just Support. 8bit BlackMage 23:26, 6 April 2008 (UTC)
I agree with that, too. -- ChiefKakashi 23:59, 7 April 2008 (UTC)
To expand on my thoughts: The reject column is important. If there's no reject column, this isn't even close to a democracy. It would be like asking an undetermined number of people "do you like this idea" and get 5 votes and you pass. What if there are 100 of us? 5% equals yes? If we do away with the reject column, I can guarantee you that you'll see a queue longer than the bible pop up. Sure, the 'democratic' system we have now is just an illusion, but I'm pretty sure I would squarely ignore anything implemented that did away with distention. On the subject of archiving pages, if someone wants to sit here and do that, by all means, though you will destroy any concept of order we have here, and you know how I like order. The only thing I like on this list is that no one should use talk templates on this page. --TacticAngel 18:29, 9 April 2008 (UTC)
- Agree with TA. We need a reject column. That much is pretty obvious to all. Comments I can live without, but I need to reject the really bad ideas. --BlueHighwind 19:06, 9 April 2008 (UTC)
- Thats more like it, more input. Like Nelo pointed out, Support/Reject columns are making this suggestion page a DNC of its own. Truth be told, TA, you can't handle the list because to follow those suggestions you'd have to spend more time here, and you've been more out than in lately. If all else, Support/Reject sections can serve as a Comment section on its own. [^_^]/ 07:19, 10 April 2008 (UTC)
- My house burnt down... I do what I can, but I've little access to the internet and less time than normal. I've resolved myself to handle the DNC as much as possible since thats one of the things for which I am known, not so much because I started it, but because when the DNC functionally was dead, I revived it. This democracy thing is a hoot. Seriously, 5 votes? Really? Rikku got 50+ votes. Not counting Yuffie voters, thats less than 10% carrying an affirmative vote. Deleting information from pages? Vandalism? Both of those are obviously really bad ideas if you want to say viva la revolution. If you want things the old way, thats fine. I don't think that the trip we've been on has improved anything. The last two fights were slaughters. --TacticAngel 03:18, 11 April 2008 (UTC)
- Thats more like it, more input. Like Nelo pointed out, Support/Reject columns are making this suggestion page a DNC of its own. Truth be told, TA, you can't handle the list because to follow those suggestions you'd have to spend more time here, and you've been more out than in lately. If all else, Support/Reject sections can serve as a Comment section on its own. [^_^]/ 07:19, 10 April 2008 (UTC)
Gabranth vs. Golbez
This idea just came to my mind. Two evil brothers of main characters. Two badass knights. And it's not as one-sided as some recent fights. Dark raven 11:05, 13 April 2008 (UTC)