No edit summary |
|||
Line 306: | Line 306: | ||
#[[User:Roman King|Roman King]] |
#[[User:Roman King|Roman King]] |
||
#[[user: bob the geomancer|bob]] |
#[[user: bob the geomancer|bob]] |
||
+ | #[[user: JARIITX|JARIITX]] |
||
===Reject=== |
===Reject=== |
Revision as of 02:53, 5 March 2008
Archives | ||
---|---|---|
|
This talk page has the purpose of helping to select what will eventually be our semi-weekly competition. If you would like to make a suggestion, please feel free to leave it here. If you would like to see what people have suggested in the past, please refer to this page's archive.
Battle of The Thieves: Locke vs Zidane
a battle between 2 thieves, let's see who is the better pickpocket
Support
Reject
- User:Henryacores: One-sided
Final Fantasy IX: Creator vs Creation, Garland vs Kuja
I was recently playing Final Fantasy 9, and this idea came too me. I believe it has not been done before, and will prove to be very interesting, as both are very different types of characters and villians. Sometimes it comes up that FF9 seems to be over looked, but look FF9 character Vivi won the Magicite Madness. So let us see who of the two villians comes out on top. p.s. Personally I perfer Garland over Kuja.
Support
- User:Henryacores: I actually like this idea! o.O
- ChiefKakashi: This would be fun.
- Alcaeus: Because I like Kuja. :)
- 00:49, 4 March 2008 (UTC): What kakashi said
Reject
- Kuja makes babies cry. And Garland isn't so much as a villain as he is a antihero. Oath
Comments
Weapon & Final Boss Battle
How about Buster Sword vs Gunblade? The battle is not one sided, I think they are some people who like the gunblade better than the sword. Other Idea is the Emperor Palamecia vs the Cloud of Darkness. Y'see, they are the less remembered final bosses in the Final Fantasy history...
Cloud of darkness vs. kefka final form? both are pretty much dietys in their own respective FF universes. | |||
FFT battle
8bit BlackMage - Beyond the Sky TALK - Why do chemists call helium, curium, and barium 'the medical elements'? Because, if you can't 'helium' or 'curium', you... um... ._.; - {{{time}}} | |||
Okay, so next week, we should have TWO fights. Ramza vs. Delita and Zalbag vs Dycedarg. And another novel idea: Why don't we commit to changing the fight exactly one week from now, next Saturday. | |||
Support
- N/A: Only for Ramza vs. Delita, though.
- BlueHighwind: Who gives a shit about those who do not care? Let them not vote.
- 8bit BlackMage :I like the new layout. We did Ramza versus Marche, that didn't even count. Who the hell would lose to Marche?!?
- Alcaeus: Both ideas are great, especially Ramza vs. Delita.
Reject
- TacticAngel: We've already done Ramza. No one votes for Tactics. No one cares.
- USer:Henryacores: Too much FFT.
- The tactics characters dont really have any skills, persay, unless you count special classes commands (like the sword saint). Tactics fights come down to who said the coolest line in the game pretty much.
Comments
How character weapons like Balthier's gun vs Vincents Cerberus
Tidus VS Auron
Here's an idea; Tidus vs. Auron!!!Roxas5000 05:04, 24 February 2008 (UTC)
Support
Reject
- TacticAngel: Of the very few characters that can beat Auron here at the FFWiki, Tidus is not one.
- TSD: Read. The. Older. Threads.
- User:Henryacores: What for?
- 00:51, 4 March 2008 (UTC):stupid idea
- Etch: way too one-sided
Comments
@Roxas: Here's and idea! ONE SIDED VOTE EVEN MORE ONE SIDED THAN FFVII VS FFVIII WITH ONLY BH VOTING. You were kidding right? Right?!?!...Shoots Roxas.Roman King - All the lonely people, where do they all come from?
TALK - Death time. 05:16, 24 February 2008 (UTC)Yeah, I don't think there would be anything left of Tidus after that unfair match.You know, putting this in a new category won't change the fact. And now I see that you WEREN'T kidding...I think I'm supposed to feel something, something akin to pity.Auron cant be beat by a wimp like tidus. like the other guy says, like only THREE people have the slightest chance of winning MAYBE if they go toe to toe with auron. MAYBE.No effing way! Read the above.
Edge vs Shadow
This fight has never been done. I think it'd be awesome. I even have them in a sandbox.Support
Reject
- TacticAngel 11:50, 25 February 2008 (UTC)
- Ivalicia
- Uinreli
Comments
nu mou v.s seeq
bob the geomancer - Do you know what cancer is? it is a piece of evil.
TALK - I had a dog once. cancer overtook him {{{time}}}two lesser known species from ivaliceSupport
- ChiefKakashi: Because I can. O_o
Reject
- BlueHighwind - they both are nothing but filthy animals
- User:Henryacores: Seeq suck hard as hell. Not worthy for the mighty Nu Mou. Could be done if it were Nu Mou vs Bangaa
- Oto: Rats vs. pigs. hmmm...
Comments
Viera v.s Baanga
bob the geomancer - Do you know what cancer is? it is a piece of evil.
TALK - I had a dog once. cancer overtook him {{{time}}}i know the other one was stupid but hey i was trying stuff outSupport
Reject
Comments
Tifa vs. Rydia
I don't think this would as one-sided as some would believe.Support
- BlueHighwind, even though the legions of mindless anti-FFVII fanboys (just as bad as pro-FFVII fanboys) will make sure that Tifa loses
- The Hexed
- 8bit_BlackMage: If my idea wasn't selected, my second choice would be this fight.
- Roman King
- TacticAngel
- bob: both are popular characters sooo it won't be all that one sided.
Reject
- Alcaeus: I'm tired of all the Tifa/Rydia fanboyism.
- N/A: I'm tired of all the lustfull comments in the voting site and the peanut gallery.
- TSD:I reject this by instinct.
Comments
8-bit, Ramza vs. Delita was my idea.8bit BlackMage - Beyond the Sky
TALK - Why do chemists call helium, curium, and barium 'the medical elements'? Because, if you can't 'helium' or 'curium', you... um... ._.; - {{{time}}}And Zalbaag vs. Dycedarg was mine. It was also my idea to put the suggestion on the page.Ya' know, because this fight is being done, shouldn't we take this down now?BATTLE OF THE AIRSHIPS!!!
has anyone thought of having an airship fight? c'mon i mean, wars up above! anyone can suggest any airship from any final fantasy game...the sky's the limit!!!
Support
- Pablo618:Only if the lunar whale is one of them ^^
Reject
- User:Henryacores: Which ones? Never mind, this would still be stupid as hell.
- Order: <sarcasm>Yeah. I'd really like to see identical flying boats fight each other.</sarcasm>
Comment
bob the geomancer - Do you know what cancer is? it is a piece of evil.
TALK - I had a dog once. cancer overtook him {{{time}}}well if were talking airships it should be the invincible vs the lunar whale, the two omega shipsCharacter Weapons
Balthier's gun vs Vincent's Cerberus
Support
Reject
- User:Oath to Order: Guns fighting each other. How exiting.
Comment
I believe that this is do-able, provided that the Death Penalty has more information and Fomalhaut gets a picture.Nobuo Uematsu VS Takeharu Ishimoto
Musician battle anyone? though I can predict this may be one sided, I want a surprise. Who is better, the great and epic composer Uematsu or this new and modernized beautiful sound of Ishimoto
Support
Reject
- ChiefKakashi: I thought at first this would be a good battle, but then I realized how far one-sided this would be.
- TSD:One-sided again...
- User:Henryacores: What TSD said
- User:Oath to Order: heh
- User:AlcaeusTheWizard: Nobuo Uematsu versus who?
Comments
I put George Gershwin (best known for "Rhapsody in Blue"), John Williams (best known for composing all the music for Star Wars), and Nobuo Uematsu all in the same category.I love rhapsody in blue. is truly a masterpieceMoogle vs Chocobo
Why not the good old fashioned battle between these to loved creatures, this battle may have been done before, however peoples' opinions change, personally I believe that this is one of those battles which could be done and done agian.
Support
- !TacticAngel
- TSD:IDK, I haven't voted on this before.
- Ivalicia
Reject
N/A: Done before.
- Oath
- ChiefKakashi: I wouldn't be able to vote...
Comments
...I hate both equally. Okay, hate is a strong word, but I really, really, really don't like them. They're annoying.Twin Battle Two
How about another twin battle? This time it would be Basch and Gabranth vs Edgar and Sabin. I know we've already done a twin thing but I think this would be an interesting fight.Support
- MK: Damn that actually doesn't sound too one sided.
- 8bit_BlackMage: I like this idea.
- Pablo618: Great idea!
- Ivalicia
Reject
[{[User:Henryacores]]: Twin battles suck.
City fight
Lets do something new. How bout a fight between cities? I suggest Bastok vs. Windurst. Cactuar83File:Highwind.jpgHighwind 01:49, 27 February 2008 (UTC)
Support
Reject
Comments
8bit BlackMage - Beyond the Sky
TALK - Why do chemists call helium, curium, and barium 'the medical elements'? Because, if you can't 'helium' or 'curium', you... um... ._.; - {{{time}}}It would be interesting, provided the cities have built in rocket launchers or something. I also have no idea what games those two cities are from, and thus have no idea what they look like.Freelancer Fight
How about a Freelancer fight, between Bartz and Luneth or Firion and Vaan (both Firion and Vaan got set jobs at a later game.)?
Support
Reject
- User:Oath to Order: Firion's a Fighter, Vaan's a Thief and Bartz and Luneth rely on multiple jobs and abilities.
- 8bit_BlackMage: Not only that, but the characters themselves son muy aburridos.
Comments
Sky Pirate Battle!
How about a fight between two swashbucklers of the skies that not only crosses the gender line, but the race line AND ultimately the friendship line? Balthier vs. Fran. This one might be a good one and I'm sure it'll be a close one. Any takers?Support
- I think Balthier vs. Fran has been done, but then we could make it a classic fight. Then again, Balthier's one of my favorites, and Fran's...I better stop there.--ChiefKakashi
Reject
- Hahaha... Balthier's an asshole. Oath to Order 03:24, 29 February 2008 (UTC)
- One sided, because everyone here worships the guy, and Fran has slightly less backstroy or development.--Otherarrow 11:12, 29 February 2008 (UTC)
- Pablo618: IS absolutely one-sided
Comments
I rather we have Zidane vs. Balthier. It would be better.Battle of the Disliked Heroines
How about a match up between two female characters people love to complain about? That's right, I'm talking about Selphie from Final Fantasy VII and Penelo from Final Fantasy XII. It would be a "lesser of two evils" type deal, and I think it would be interesting to see who takes the cake. -- Blykus
Support
Reject
Don't think "lesser of two evils" is the way to put it. I don't think this one will pass.- Why would we vote for people we don't like?--ChiefKakashi
- Pablo618: I like penelo xD but the fight is boring
Comments
Zeromus vs Jenova
A revist of an old favorite
Support
MK: both were mindcontrolling bastards
Reject
Comments
Kuja vs Kefka
As recommended by Alceus. The clown versus the cross-dresser.
Support
Alcaeus: Since I thought of it earlier.
- Ivalicia
- Etch: hmm, a gender confused makeup-wearing queer vs a psychotic makeup wearing clown, sounds interesting.
- ChiefKakashi: Despite the fact that Kuja will probably get Pwned, I would like to see this one.
Reject
Comments
and I must express my apologies for being an asshole in the archives, sorry.--N/A
Don't worry about it. I shouldn't have called you that. --Alcaeus
Battle of the Princesses
A battle of the strong-willed princesses, Garnet vs Ashe. These gals aren't like Peach, they can take care of themselves, though a meat-shield is always nice to have. And, no, this is not about who's sexier. -- Alcaeus
Support
Reject
- For that Zelda comment, I'm rejecting it. Oath to Order 00:56, 4 March 2008 (UTC)
Comments
Zelda can take care of herself. In Ocarina of Time, she becomes Shiek, pretty much the only person who fights Ganondorf for the seven years that Link is trapped in limbo. And in Wind Waker she's the leader of a band of pirates. And she doesn't have to cross-dress to get her crew's respect, unlike some. Its her arrows that help kill Ganon in the end. Even in Twilight Princess she keeps on fighting.
Peach, on the other hand, can't do anything.Agreed.AlcaeusTheWizard - is now actually contributing...well, not really
TALK - Force shites upon Reason's back. -Ben Franklin, Poor Richard's Almanack, 1736. {{{time}}}Okay, okay. Sheesh. I'll change it to Peach.Balthier vs. Auron
How 'bout it? Both have fanboys (and girls), especially Balthier, but I think there are enough people who like Auron and/or hate Balthier to make it even. I didn't look, has this been done before?Support
- Chief: Because I want to see it.
- Roman King
- bob
- JARIITX
Reject
Comments
Auron vs. Cloud
Roxas5000 01:22, 5 March 2008 (UTC) I'd like to know who'd win this fight.